Something I couldn’t hold back…
I have now seen the Lifehouse ‘Everything’ - Skit being discussed online in a couple of different places. It is a production by a group of what I believe are real and well meaning Christians, but I think it misses the mark. I refrained from posting a reply in either of the places I saw it discussed because in both places it was receiving very positive feedback and I felt my comments would be taken as divisive and obtuse, though they are certainly not meant to be either. But having watched the video a few times and read the reactions, I felt I just had to respond somewhere. Then I remembered I have my very own soapbox here at auldridges.com.
I am going to come off as an elitist and such a ‘negative-Nancy’. That is not intended. I just think we continue to miss the mark in the church today and believe we need to continually set the bar higher. So here is my own dogmatic and purposely limited response:
1) God does not have to fight for us, nor is he held helplessly at bay by the evils of the world as they work against us. Having already won the fight for His people, He actively grants and revokes capability to the evils of the world to act against us all the while maintaining sovereignty over the entire situation.
2) The real power that unites us to God is missing in this portrayal. It is the life and death of Jesus Christ, and faith alone in His deity and redeeming work which unites us to God. While that may be implied given the context of this production, its further display throughout the world removes that context and creates, what looks to me like, a fairly nonexclusive and unitarian feeling message. Christ’s message–The Gospel–is exclusive in its means and modes and I believe it is important to portray that.
3) The modern evangelical church, especially in America, resorts to emotional manipulation rather than solid theology and doctrine through the exposition of the Word. Proper teaching and discipling should reveal the Word and character of God, which itself will then fuel emotion. Christ told us to go into the world and make disciples. Emotional manipulation may create “converts” but will fail in creating disciples.
So there you go. My take on it. As I said, I do not believe I am ‘more Christian’ than those who put that production together, and I really believe it was put together with the most honest and pure of intentions. I really believe, however, that we have to be very particular in our accurate representation of God and His work for us.
Thanks for reading.
--Jim





